The unique new series employs parallel narratives to take viewers through gripping true-crime cases from two sides. In each episode, the audience is immersed in two conflicting narratives to hear never-before-revealed information directly from the victims and perpetrators. The audience then assumes the role of armchair detective to deduce and piece together various truths. There are two sides to every tale, and there's no telling how far someone might go for their spouse, child, or lifestyle. Within this distinctive narrative structure, each episode concludes by exposing critical details from the decided cases, prompting the viewer to ask, "Who Do You Believe?"